The hype around the launch of Benefit’s new mascara, Roller Lash, was crazy. I could not go on any form of social media without being inundated with news about this mascara. And to be honest I kind of rolled my eyes. Benefit had two other mascaras prior to launching this: Bad Gal and They’re Real! I found Bad Gal to be very average and not at all impressive or worth the price tag. They’re Real is an incredible mascara but it’s basically IMPOSSIBLE to remove without ripping out 30% of your eyelashes, so I rarely use it.
With this track record, I wasn’t all that jazzed about Roller Curl. But, as a mascara obsessive I finally broke down and figured I should investigate for myself and report my findings to you. And I’m so glad I did! Guys, this mascara is great.
The whole shtick with this is that it’s inspired by hair curlers and so curls and lifts your lashes. As y’all know, I’m a volume kind of girl. Curly, separated lashes are lovely – they’re just not my end-game and I absolutely wouldn’t sacrifice volume to achieve that. So I had no doubt that this mascara would provide good lift as well as definition due to the plastic brush, but I didn’t have high hopes for volume.
I am happy to have been proven wrong! This is a great all-rounder mascara: it gives good separation and there’s definitely no clumpiness in sight, but it still gives great volume so that your lashes look really plush and full. It also builds on itself really well, so you can layer on those coats if you want really thick, full lashes (I’d say I do 3-4 coats – which is fairly normal for me). I can’t really say if it holds a curl particular well, as I always curl my eyelashes everyday regardless. I wouldn’t say this replaces an eyelash curler – I don’t think a mascara or any product can replicate the physical effects of curling your eyelashes with a curler.
The kitschy packaging is cute, as with all Benefit products. The brush is good – it’s a very thin, bristled plastic brush. Benefit claims it’s patent-pending! Are they taking their brush a bit too seriously here? Answer: yes – it is good, but I don’t think it’s revolutionary. They also clearly learned their mistake from They’re Real being flipping impossible to remove, as they say right in their product description that it’s easy to remove. And it is!
Overall I think this is a really good mascara and I’m happy with it. In terms of volume I still prefer Tarte’s Lights, Camera Lashes, but this is still quite good and I’m really enjoying using it.
- formula: 8/10
- brush: 8/10
- overall look: 8/10
What do you think of Roller Lash – do you like it? What’s your favourite mascara that I should try next?
Ohhh it looks so good! Now the hype’s died down a bit I’m considering buying it a bit more as people still clearly love it… and I’m glad to hear it’s easier to remove! x
LikeLike
I know, I was so skeptical of all the hype! But it actually IS really good. Thank goodness that it’s not as hard to remove as They’re Real, what a nightmare!
LikeLiked by 1 person
great review, I’ve heard mixed reviews about this mascara, may have to give it a go myself!
LikeLike
thanks! If you want a good combo of volume and length, give it a go!
LikeLike
You should try Youniques 3D lash fiber mascara! This stuff is amazing! And they have a great no questions refund policy if you don’t like the product. https://www.youniqueproducts.com/LaSarah/products/view/US-1017-00#.VSwc2saCPCQ
LikeLike
I have tried it! I wasn’t too crazy about it but maybe I’ll give it another try.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve found it takes some getting used to.
LikeLike
This mascara is on my wishlist. But I have so many other mascaras to get through first before I buy any new ones.
LikeLike
totally know the feeling! which ones are you loving lately?
LikeLike
I have SO MUCH trouble finding mascara! I don’t wear it very often, so when I do put some on, I want something that’s easy to apply and easy to remove. This looks like it could be the one!
https://forsevenseasons.wordpress.com
LikeLiked by 1 person
This one is definitely good! But for ones that apply super quickly and well, also consider Tarte’s Lights, Cameras, Lashes and Bourjois Volume 1 Seconde! These three are probably my top three right now. Rimmel are also almost always great
LikeLike